Saturday, 1 May 2010
The last post...for now
See you later and in the meantime THANK YOU FOR USING THE BLOG.
Julie Rainey
Wednesday, 28 April 2010
Outcome of the EQIA
Julie Rainey, Liz Breadon and Pauline Frazer attended the NI Assembly Education Committee Meeting today (28th April), to hear the Department of Education's
Departmental Briefing on Outcome of draft EQIA and the Minister’s decision to withdraw part of the Funding to Prep. Departments of Grammar Schools
Many of you have asked what the Minister of Education's justification was for cutting the funding by 1/3 if the issue was based on equality. Department of Education officials were asked this question by members of the Education Committee. John McGrath, DE Deputy Secretary, explained that the Education Minister was "continuing the trajectory" on from previous funding cuts in 1994 (50% to 40%) and 1998 (40% to 30%). She did not feel this was "out of kilter" to make the reduction to 20% (i.e. the what the "reduced by 1/3" means). She had taken consideration of responses and advice given to her and therefore was not removing the funding altogether as previously proposed, though she was still of the personal opinion that prep funding was inequitable.
There was no indication that anything was in the pipeline in future years with regard to further cuts. It was referred to that the previous cuts were in 1998. There was plenty of opportunity for DE officials to indicate if there any plans and there was nothing to report. They said no Departments at all could make guarantees for years down the line.
Interestingly at the end of the session, a Sinn Fein Committee Member said of the Minister "she was damned if she did and damned if she didn't".
It was suggested by Committee Members that perhaps the Minister had 'saved face" with the 1/3 cut.
That’s the explanation we got.
Monday, 26 April 2010
A very big thank you
Dear Parents & Guardians
The Board of Governors' letter on Friday 23 April was a welcome summation of the sentiments & determination felt by the whole school following the announcement at the Education Committee at Stormont last week.
As a Parents’ Group, we want to add a huge ‘thank you’ of our own to you all. As a small working party we have been highly reliant on your support, timely response to calls for action &, above all, your ability to hold your nerve throughout a stressful few months. We very much appreciate the trust you placed in us & in the information & advice we provided. Testament to this has been the net minimal disruption to pupil numbers & the new pupils joining the school throughout this turbulent period.
Above all, we appreciate the barrage of letters & emails you sent to DENI & other external bodies, MLAs & to OFMDFM, both initial letters & follow up letters, to keep the pressure up. You should be under no illusion, that without this we would not be where we are today, as it was clear that it was not just the volume of correspondence, but the personal arguments posed which were crucial to the outcome. Recent soundbites from OFMDFM indicate this has been the most professional & aggressive campaign & lobbying they have EVER seen & we understand the correspondence received by OFMDFM numbered in the thousands! Do stand back, think about this & be proud that you, the people representing 1.5% of the pupil population of Northern Ireland, did this & that in doing so, you have invested in your childrens’ future educational rights & standards.
It is with some sorrow that we will see RHSprepfunding.blogspot.com wind down in its current form. We have, however, decided not to kill it off completely as, now established, we feel it may be a useful communication tool for wider ‘prep communications’ in future. Watch this space!
Please also be reassured that the Education Minister is certainly not off our radar! We continue to be vigilant & liaise on the political, inter-prep school & legal fronts, maintaining the relationships & completing the work of recent months
Regards
RHS Prep Parents’ Group
Sunday, 25 April 2010
Full steam ahead for Regent House Prep
Wednesday, 21 April 2010
McIlveen welcomes Ruane U-turn
DUP Education Committee Member, Michelle McIlveen has welcomed the Education Minister’s U-turn on Preparatory Department funding. The Minister has decided to continue funding for the Preparatory Department’s for the forthcoming year but the funding is to be reduced by 1/3. Commenting on the decision the DUP member for Strangford said:
“Clearly, the fact that the Preparatory Departments are to continue to receive funding is very welcome news, although that funding is to be reduced by 1/3. Preparatory Departments represent fantastic value for money in terms of the results and to remove that funding totally would have resulted in an additional burden on the Education Budget. It is a relief to many of those parents who send their children to Preparatory Departments, particularly in these fraught financial times, that funding will continue. It is also a relief for the children at these schools who faced uncertainty whether they would still be going to their school next year. The DUP has been fighting hard for those parents and children in bringing this matter to the fore.
This U-turn has been carried out in the face of extreme pressure not only from DUP, but by extremely concerned parents who care about their children being used as political pawns by Caitriona Ruane in pursuit of her educational jihad. She has been seen to crumble under that pressure. The uncertainty that has been created due to the Minister’s dithering over this funding issue is nothing short of disgraceful and can only have resulted in having a negative impact on the children. In light of this we will now be having discussions with the sector as to how we deal with this issue given the damage which has been done.”
Source - http://www.dup.org.uk/default.htm
PREP FUNDING IS SECURED!
The Minister also outlined her decision on the funding for preparatory schools in the future following the recent consultation process on the draft Equality Impact Assessment.
The Minister said: "My position on this issue has always been that funding of Preparatory Departments is an inequitable use of public money. I have given conscientious consideration to the responses to the EQIA and recognise that ending the funding completely may cause difficulties for parents and possible disruption in some schools. I have therefore decided to continue funding Preparatory Departments, but at a reduced level. The current level of funding will be reduced by one third from September 2010."
Saturday, 17 April 2010
NICCY supports us.
Friday, 16 April 2010
Prep funding decision 'by end of April'
RHS Prep Parents' Group returned to Stormont today to hear Education Committee meeting with DENI officials
Wednesday, 14 April 2010
Let's hear what the Election candidates have to say!
RHS Prep Parents' Group returned to Stormont today to hear Education Committee meeting with DENI officials
Witnesses:
John McGrath – Deputy Secretary
Roisin Lilley – School Finance Branch
Paul Duffy – Accounts Branch
Tuesday, 13 April 2010
ACTION REQUIRED- Follow up letters
- the matter remains unresolved causing considerable upset and worry to parents, children and teachers
- we have already entered the final term for the school year and seek an assurance that every effort will be made to ensure that families are not left in a position where their children have no assurance that their schooling arrangements will not be thrown into disarray by ill advised decision making or lack of it by the Education Minister.
As a concerned Regent House School Preparatory Department parent whose SEELB "controlled" prep department could face closure if prep funding is withdrawn, I am hoping that you might have some further information on where the situation is at currently and if there has been any decision made. Please could you provide me with an update or information at this time?
As a concerned parent I am keen to make sure this issue does not get brushed under the carpet and that a positive outcome for our children and teachers is achieved quickly.
I look forward to hearing from you on this issue.
Your sincerely
Finance Minister - "I believe that the Education Minister is guilty of a terminological inexactitude"
During the NI Assembly debate (15.03.10) on the proposal to withdraw funding from preparatory departments, the DUP’s Jonathan Bell was ordered from the chamber after he refused to withdraw his comment that the Education Minister, Caitriona Ruane, was "deliberately mislead(ing) the House" by associating the Finance Minister, Sammy Wilson, with a report from the Assembly’s Business Consultancy Service which had actually been commissioned by the Education Minister. In the Assembly today 13.03.10, the Finance Minister decided to pick up up on this point again...
Saturday, 10 April 2010
Post Easter update - progress made...
12 April 2010
Dear Parents & Guardians,
Welcome back after the Easter break! Even though we have been off school & the Assembly have likewise been on recess for the same 2 weeks, progress continues to be made in a number of areas.
The Executive
To recap, the Executive are the 10 Ministers at Stormont (eg Minister for Education, Minister for Finance etc.). Of these 10 Ministers, 7 belong to political parties who supported the motion at the Assembly on 15 March, 6 being Unionist & only 3 are Sinn Fein.
In the weeks running up to the Easter holidays we asked you to write to the Office of the First & Deputy First Minister (‘OFMDFM’) requesting & giving your reasons why you believed the matter of Prep school funding should be addressed at Executive level. The aim of this was to ensure the Executive determine whether the Education Minister’s failure to refer her proposals to them for consideration is a breach of the Ministerial Code (ie under the following categories: novel, contentious and cross-cutting, the latter 2 being particularly applicable).
It was important to try to progress this next step in the political process prior to Easter, bearing in mind the ensuing 2 week recess. This ‘letter-writing’ campaign which was initiated by RHS, was spread to & supported across the Prep school population of NI, resulting in the matter being on the Executive’s agenda on the Thursday before the Easter break. Thank you so much for your support for this effort!
The First Minister has now, as a result of this meeting, referred the matter to OFMDFM’s Departmental solicitors regarding whether the matter should, indeed, be dealt with by the Executive. We await feedback on this after the Assembly resumes this week.
Equality Impact Assessment (EQIA)
Your responses to the EQIA were sent to Chris McRoberts by 4 March 2010. To recap, DENI advised that before the Minister for Education made her decision, she would be supplied with a report summarising the points raised in the responses submitted to the EQIA.
The Forward Work Plan of the Education Committee of the Assembly was updated on 31 March to indicate that the 14 & 21 April agendas include a ‘Departmental briefing on the outcome of the draft EQIA on proposal to withdraw funding from Prep School Departments of Grammar Schools’.
We are also aware from the Minister for Education’s written responses to questions tabled at the Assembly on 26 March that:
“To date, my Department has catalogued: 432 responses to the draft Equality Impact Assessment; 70 Ministerial Correspondence letters; 27 General Mail letters; 15 Departmental Web Mail letters; and 6 General Correspondence letters.” (Source:
http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/qanda/2007mandate/writtenans/2009/100326.htm#4)
That's 550 responses/letters! A very encouraging response, I’m sure you will agree.
We remain in close contact with the Chair & other representatives on the Education Committee in this regard, & will update you as information is received.
Northern Ireland Children’s Commissioner (NICCY)
We have progressed the issue further with external bodies, including NICCY, thereby heightening their awareness & concerns regarding the particular issues faced by the Preparatory Departments of the 3 Controlled schools. We have asked the Children’s Commissioner to comment on these issues specifically & provide an addendum to their original response to the Department of Education.
Legal
Preparations have been made to seek redress through the Courts by means of judicial review immediately should the Minister for Education make an adverse decision. Anyone wishing to become involved in this process or having any queries in this regard, should contact Michelle Edgar at John Ross & Son on 02891 813173
Budgets
You may be aware that all Northern Ireland schools, & indeed many other public sector Departments, did not receive their budgets for the financial year commencing 1 April by that date. We understand this is not an unusual occurrence in the public sector, but clearly one that causes consternation & inconvenience to the Education Boards. Those of you who subscribe to rhsprepfunding.blogspot.com will have noted the comments of Michelle McIlveen MLA in this regard & know that this is being pursued to conclusion by MLAs.
Other Schools
As alluded to above in respect of OFDFM lobbying, we remain in close contact with the other 15 affected schools &, in particular, the 2 other schools in the Controlled sector, to ensure our efforts are effective & co-ordinated.
We still need your help……….
It is vitally important we continue to all we can to ensure this issue is kept in the spotlight as much as possible ie to ensure it remains ‘contentious’.
In the incoming weeks, we are mounting a fresh ‘assault’ on the media. Already press releases have been issued at national level to TV, press & radio, but we are aware front page news is not possible on a daily basis.
The Education Minister has 1 argument being ‘equality of access; we have many more in our favour & we are keen to drive home those messages on the editorial column inches & ‘letters to the editor’ sections of as many national & local newspapers as possible. We have a complete list of these publications & are keen to have a co-ordinated approach, encompassing as many of these papers on as many related topics as possible. Some of you may have noted our own Alison Montgomery’s letter to the editor of the Belfast Telegraph last weekend! If you feel strongly about any particular area or, if directed towards a topical area, you would be willing to type up a few lines to a newspaper, please contact Liz Breadon on 07720 275452, Sarah Schűtzler on 07809 373385 or Nicola Hunter on 07971 874940. You have proved to be highly effective letter lobbyists in the past weeks – please continue to help us to help you!
As we all pick up the pace again in the incoming weeks, we thank you for your ongoing support. As parents ourselves, we do appreciate you may still naturally have some concerns, but, as a group, we continue to be encouraged by the nature & speed of progress at all levels.
Yours sincerely
RHS Parents’ Group
Wednesday, 7 April 2010
Department of Education receives 550 responses/letters to EQIA
NI Assembly - Written Answers to Questions - Friday 26th March 2010
Department of Education
Preparatory Departments of Grammar Schools
Mr A Ross asked the Minister of Education to detail any correspondence she has received,to date, opposing her proposal to withdraw funding from the preparatory departments of grammar schools. (AQW 5458/10)
As you know my Department commissioned the Business Consultancy Service of the Department of Finance and Personnel, in January 2009, to independently undertake a review of the funding to preparatory departments following on from recommendations in the Bain Report and to provide a report of their findings. Their Report, which was provided to me in September 2009, concluded that the Department should consider the withdrawal of funding to preparatory departments on the basis of equality of access.
This recommendation was in line with the view of the Equality Commission, which stated in its document "Every Child an Equal Child" that a key component of a quality education system is the provision of equality of access to good education.
However, before reaching a decision on this recommendation, I asked for an Equality Impact Assessment (EQIA) to be carried out under Section 75 of the 1998 Northern Ireland Act. The EQIA consultation closed on 4 March 2010 and I will give conscientious consideration to the responses received to this consultation prior to making my decision.
To date, my Department has catalogued: 432 responses to the draft Equality Impact Assessment; 70 Ministerial Correspondence letters; 27 General Mail letters; 15 Departmental Web Mail letters; and 6 General Correspondence letters.
Source
http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/qanda/2007mandate/writtenans/2009/100326.htm#4
Per capita spend on schools
NI Assembly - Written Answers for Questions - Friday 26th March 2010
Department of Education
Per Capita Spend on Schools
Mr J Shannon asked the Minister of Education how much her Department has spent, per capita, on (i) Irish-medium primary schools; (ii) preparatory departments of grammar schools; (iii) controlled primary schools; and (iv) maintained primary schools, in each of the last three years.
(AQW 5359/10)
The latest full financial year for which this data is available is 2008/09. The amount of per capita delegated and non-delegated recurrent expenditure for each of the financial years 2006/07, 2007/08 and 2008/09 is shown in the table below.
| Delegated and Non-Delegated Expenditure Per Capita (£) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2006/07 | 2007/08 | 2008/09 | |
| Irish Medium Primary Schools | 3,306 | 3,575 | 3,950 |
| Controlled Primary Schools | 3,046 | 3,288 | 3,577 |
| Maintained Primary Schools | 3,036 | 3,261 | 3,458 |
| Preparatory Department of Grammar | 816 | 871 | 902 |
Footnotes:
- Expenditure information in relation to Irish-medium Units, attached to English-medium host schools has not been provided as it is not possible to disaggregate the expenditure of the Unit from the host school.
- Expenditure information in relation to the preparatory departments attached to three Controlled Grammar Schools has not been included as the SEELB has advised that it is not possible to disaggregate the expenditure of the preparatory departments from the host grammar schools. The number of pupils attending these three preparatory departments has not therefore been included in the per capita calculations for the three years listed in table above.
Source - http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/qanda/2007mandate/writtenans/2009/100326.htm#4
Latest update re EQIA
The Education Committee (of the NI Assembly) Forward Work Plan has been updated on the NI Assembly website on 31st March 2010.
www.niassembly.gov.uk/education/2007mandate/education_forward.htm
It appears that the date of 14th April 2010 will be the day for the following;
Policy Scrutiny - Departmental Briefing on Outcome of draft EQIA on proposal to withdraw funding from Prep School Departments of Grammar Schools
Also 21st April 2010.
Education budget delay criticised
Education Minister making April Fools of schools
Assembly Education Committee member Michelle McIlveen has criticised the Minister of Education for causing chaos as a result of her failure to provide them with budgets in time for the new financial year. The DUP spokesperson for children and young people, said:
"This unprecedented predicament, whereby a new financial year is starting without proper budgets being given to schools and education boards, is utterly unacceptable. I recently criticised Caitriona Ruane for leaving it later and later each year to deliver these budgets, but by failing to produce even by March 31 she has created a serious situation rather than mere inconvenience and last-minute panic.
One of a number of worrying consequences is that dozens of frontline staff whose posts are subject to the continuation of earmarked funding have not known until this week whether or not they will have a job after March 31. I understand that those in this position have now been written to by their employers indicating that they will be employed for April anyway - but, like everyone else, the Education Boards are in the dark as to what will happen thereafter as the Minister has made no decisions in relation to earmarked funding.
This is no way to treat dedicated staff, who are providing valuable and important services. It is also no way to run an education system, especially at a time of acute budgetary pressures. At a time when there is such pressure on resources, proper planning and prudent management are essential if maximum efficiencies are to be achieved - but Boards and schools are being given no chance to apply the rigorous processes they would wish to. Special dispensations have had to be given to allow Boards to continue beyond March 31 and draw down an interim allocation of funding in the absence of a proper budget for the new financial year. Boards have been given an initial allocation equating to a quarter of last year's opening recurrent budget and an additional sum for minor works - accompanied by a warning from the Department of Education that this allocation may in no way reflect the overall funding picture for the new financial year!
As Boards have been unable, through no fault of their own, to complete their formal resource allocation planning process, DE has simply sought written assurances from Chief Executives that they will, in effect, act responsibly until further notice. Placing the onus on Education Boards to essentially muddle through is inimical to proper planning and contrary to the principles and practice of good governance. Meanwhile, even though the new financial year is now here, the budgetary information received so far by schools has been negligible at best. Being left in the dark will delay any decisions which may have to be made in relation to redundancies and so forth - which of course also have implications for the individuals involved.
"The upshot is that, on the first day of the new financial year, I can only conclude that the Minister is making April Fools of our education professionals and support staff who will bear the brunt of this shameful shambles and suffer further erosion of their morale."
Saturday, 27 March 2010
Prep funding - it's a hot topic...
http://eye-on-the-hill.blogspot.com/2010/03/clowns-to-left-of-me-jokers-to-right.html
http://bobballs.wordpress.com/2010/03/03/quiet-middle-class-riot-in-progress/
Friday, 26 March 2010
Strangford MLA meets Children's Commissioner on Prep School Funding
The trauma that prep school pupils are unnecessarily being put through has been raised directly with the Children’s Commissioner by Strangford DUP MLA Jonathan Bell. Jonathan Bell MLA sought the meeting after being contacted by a parent of a Prep school child with special educational needs. Speaking after the meeting with Patricia Lewsley at the NICCY Headquarters in Belfast Jonathan Bell MLA stated;
“Rarely have I seen children put through such unnecessary trauma and stress as this ludicrous consultation on withdrawing Prep school funding by September 2010. Is it not now widely acknowledged that it is a case of when not if this ill-thought through proposal to withdraw funding by 2010 falls.
I specifically raised the plight of children with special educational needs as I am aware that the trauma of facing removal from their school, isolation from their peers/friends, dislocation from teaching supports of which a productive educational relationship has been formed – is causing stress and undue pressure. Put bluntly as the Minister for Education fiddles with their educational future vulnerable children in my constituency are suffering emotional distress.
I welcome strongly the Children’s Commissioner going public and placing her view on this matter into the public domain. Patricia Lewsley said:
“However, the method the Minister is using to end such funding is not in the best interest of the child, and is potentially causing undue distress.”
The question must be asked - Does the best interest of the child and the potential for causing them undue distress surely not trump the ideology of the Education Minister?”
SOURCE: http://www.dup.org.uk/default.htmLATEST NEWS